Free Bets

Next Race Off

Home / News / Sutcliffe Says: The Cheltenham ground debacle, Paul Nicholls equals Martin Pipe’s record & Harry Cobden’s perfect match

Sutcliffe Says: The Cheltenham ground debacle, Paul Nicholls equals Martin Pipe’s record & Harry Cobden’s perfect match

Sutcliffe Says: The Cheltenham ground debacle, Paul Nicholls equals Martin Pipe’s record & Harry Cobden’s perfect match

With the November Meeting at Cheltenham in the books, Matty Sutcliffe reflects on a weekend dominated by ground issues, Paul Nicholls drawing level with Martin Pipe’s record and Harry Cobden’s big-race double for JP McManus.

This weekend promised so much. Old Park Star versus Kabral Du Mathan. Jonbon versus Gidleigh Park. The return of Idaho Sun. Do you remember asking for brazen gifts for Christmas as a child, only to unwrap a pair of oversized jeans your mum said you’d ‘grow into’? That’s what this weekend was like.

Non-runners galore and slippery bends – the Cheltenham ground debacle

Now, I must stress that I’m no expert on maintaining a perfect racing surface, nor on drainage systems. But the going situation over the weekend at Cheltenham was nothing short of farcical for all involved.

It was only last January that the Cheltenham ground team discovered a hole in the track on Trials Day, which forced the course to spend a large sum of money on drainage works. Subsequently, Cheltenham was forced to cancel its final three meetings of last season. Fast forward nine months and the home of National Hunt racing still suffered issues with the track across the November Meeting.

According to the BHA, Friday began on ground officially described as good, good to soft in places. The track was supposedly watered as much as Jon Pullin and his team could manage in the lead-up to the meeting following the October Showcase. Good, good to soft in places. 5.6 on the GoingStick. The Showcase meeting returned readings of 6.3 and 6.5 and was described by the Racing Post as good to soft. Work that one out.

Friday saw nine non-runners across the card, six due to the ground, the majority of them high-profile horses. Gidleigh Park came out of the Shloer, leaving Jonbon to beat what were essentially handicappers. King’s Bucks joined Derryhassen Paddy in coming out of the Listed novices’ chase, which saw a horse rated 123 sent off favourite.

Three horses slipped on the bend turning for home, while two of the races were run quicker than standard, with the rest not far off. Not only was the ground nowhere near ‘good to soft’ in places, it was undoubtedly not what you’d expect National Hunt ground to be in the middle of November. Horses slipping posed not only a welfare issue but a risk to the meeting going forward.

Now, the clerks seemingly have an impossible task, and given the circumstances – a changing climate and a rare dry summer – I don’t think anyone is suggesting they could do better.

Onto Saturday. 6.6 on the GoingStick (not exactly much higher than the 6.3 and 6.5 from the October meeting). Good, good to firm in places. The track did not water due to freezing temperatures. 29 non-runners.

For the home of our sport, a prestigious track hosting a meeting whose attendance is second only to the Festival in March, 29 non-runners is a damning indictment of the course’s condition, not only for owners and trainers but for punters, both as a viewing and a betting spectacle.

The Arkle Trial was affected the most. I’d imagine a large percentage of racegoers attended in the hope of seeing the early-season clash between Old Park Star and Kabral Du Mathan. Neither lined up, and the Grade 2, which has been won by smart types in the past, went to a 128-rated summer chaser.

The Paddy Power Gold Cup saw four come out on account of the ground.

Onto Sunday. 6.6 on the GoingStick. ‘Good’ ground. No firmness. That was the same reading as the previous day, which the BHA had described as good to firm in places. 8mm of irrigation was applied overnight, followed by 15mm of rainfall prior to racing – 23mm in total. The track was under review due to standing water on the bend. 16 non-runners, including the Greatwood Hurdle favourite Idaho Sun.

The times were soft. The bumper looked as if it was run in a bog.

I understand clerks have an impossible task, and I’m not going to provide any analysis or advice on how to produce suitable going. But with a combined 54 non-runners, several of the meeting’s ‘big’ horses not running and three separate going descriptions that were open to debate, this was one of the most farcical meetings ever staged at the track, and there’s no sugar-coating it. How can the sport’s participants – owners, trainers, jockeys and punters – trust the course to provide not only a suitable surface but a product worth watching and betting on?

If the track’s drainage system is not suitable for this changing climate, is it time to be worried about the Festival going forward?

3,930 not out – Paul Nicholls equals Martin Pipe’s record

On a lighter note, Paul Nicholls finally equalled Martin Pipe’s record as Britain’s winningmost jumps trainer in history when Fasol won by a short head under Freddie Gingell at Windsor. It’s been a turbulent time for Nicholls of late, but we mustn’t forget his brilliance and the way he’s shaped British racing, not least in producing his successor as champion trainer, Dan Skelton.

To provide context for such admirable longevity at the top, Nicholls’ first winner came in 1991 with Olveston. Freddie Gingell was born 14 years later.

Nicholls very nearly became the sole holder of the record straight away, but Pourquoi Pas Papa could only manage second to Sony Bill at Cheltenham on Sunday.

The Ditcheat handler will have to wait until Thursday for his next runners, with five entered at Warwick, to claim sole ownership of the prestigious title. Two of them are in a race sponsored by Olly Murphy, who was once Paul Nicholls’ assistant.

Knappers Hill would be an appropriate winner given he’s running in the veterans’ chase, whereas Ellie Marie, who’s from the family of Martin Pipe’s 2005 Arkle winner Contraband, would represent a poignant changing of the guard.

Harry Cobden and JP McManus – a perfect match

One of the few positives to emerge from Cheltenham this weekend was the brilliance of Harry Cobden. Cobden has already had a career most jockeys could only dream of, yet he’s still just 28, and his partnership with JP McManus can propel him to another level.

With the decline of talent emerging from Ditcheat in recent years, Cobden’s appearances in the winner’s enclosure at the pinnacle of the sport declined in tandem. He’s no doubt still learning the ropes as JP McManus’ retained rider, particularly at the Irish tracks, but he confirmed his brilliance at Cheltenham this weekend.

The first came on Jonbon, one of JP’s favourite horses. The ten-year-old found little fluency under Nico de Boinville last season, but under an aggressive Cobden ride, he put in one of the best rounds of jumping of his career to land the Shloer. It might not have been his best performance in terms of ratings, but at this stage of his career he’s entitled to need the run, and almost certainly a further trip.

A day later, the newly formed team had the well-touted favourite in the Paddy Power Gold Cup, Meetmebythesea. Despite a glittering career as an owner, the 75-year-old McManus had yet to win the November showpiece. No stranger to pressure or success, Cobden kept it cool from the front. He found a rhythm, only asked for big jumps when needed and stormed up the hill to justify favouritism.

The two successes were a crowning moment for Cobden, one that confirms the belief JP McManus has shown in awarding him such a coveted role, and we can expect to see further brilliance in the coming years.

Eye-catcher of the week – Kildinan Prince, Saturday 13:25 Windsor

If ever a horse embodied the phrase ‘not off’, it was Kildinan Prince at Windsor on Saturday. The Leading Light gelding was favourite for the race before declarations and in the lead-up to Saturday, but he was very easy to back throughout the morning and drifted out to second favourite.

He was held up in last under Ben Jones throughout, before storming home for fifth, seemingly with plenty left in the tank. He looks well handicapped off a mark of 120, and I suspect the yard will try to win a Pertemps qualifier and protect his mark for March thereafter.